4 Pros and Cons Video

Blackmagic is continuing to change the game with their new camera the Blackmagic Pocket Cinema Camera 4K. From someone who transitioned from a Canon Rebel t2i to the Blackmagic Pocket Cinema Camera, this release blew mind. In fact, I didn’t even believe it was real at first.

Having been a regular on several Blackmagic forums (specifically the BMPCC facebook group), I was familiar with the shit posts that announced fake releases of new gear. So when I saw a photo of the supposedly new Blackmagic Pocket Cinema Camera 4k on a billboard, I assumed it was fake. Every Blackmagic forum I was on started to grow to a frenzy. The gossip grew louder and I started to believe something might actually be going on.

It was hard to believe. Us Blackmagic users had been asking for this camera for years. We jokingly wondered “what if the BMPCC had 4k? It would blow everything out of the water.” People argued whether or not Blackmagic would do this and even whether or not other companies would let them do this. So when DSLR Video Shooter’s Caleb Pike dropped the video aptly titled “Blackmagic Pocket Cinema 4k is Happening,” the Blackmagic community erupted with excitement.

Blackmagic-Pocket-Cinema-Camera-4K-news-update

After reviewing the BMPCC 4K’s tech specs and multiple demo videos, I’ve consolidated what I believe are the camera’s four pros and four cons. Now, these are four pros and cons that are coming from a Blackmagic fan and someone who has used Blackmagic products for a good portion of the lifespan the cameras have been available. My pros are what excited me in the camera and the cons are what I found to be disappointments. So let’s get to it.

The Pros

1. Price

The price cannot be overlooked on this camera. Consumers tend to expect a certain value with the best new releases and Blackmagic user especially look for this. But with this incredible technology and load of features bundled into this camera, the price can’t simply be overlooked.

For $1,295, you will be receiving what most competitors can only afford to offer at double the cost, and this camera is debatably greater. That’s insane.

2. 4K Resolution

Yes, yes of course, the camera now has 4K resolution. Hallelujah! Personally I’m not too big on this feature (especially considering the data requirement that will be necessary), but I know too many people who are. I feel it’s a bit of a shame, but some people won’t even look at a camera unless it’s 4k.

4K, in addition to making the cameras images sharper and more detailed, will also allow freelancers to check this box off for their clientele.

3. Max 25,600 ISO

This is probably the single biggest reason I want to get this camera in my hands. I know people who were unhappy with the first BMPCC’s low light capabilities. I was never one of those people.

However, having this camera’s ISO max boosted up to 25,600 excites the hell out of me. If you would have told me my first BMPCC could go from a max ISO of 1,600 to 25,600, I would have had a hard time even imagining the capability. So I can’t wait to see what that looks like.

4. 120 Frames Per Second

Sweet sweet slo-mo. There was a long period of time I was jealous, and even considering, the Blackmagic Micro Cinema Camera simply for its 60 fps slo-mo capability. As a filmmaker who frequently does narrative influenced work, slo-mo would make a great addition to my tool kit.

Blackmagic Design recognized the original BMPCC’s shortcoming of only being able to shoot at a max of 30 fps and fixed the problem not only by adding 60 fps, but boosted it up to 120 fps.

Honorable Mentions

1. Davinci Resolve Studio

Now when you purchase the BMPCC 4K, you will also receive one of the most powerful editing softwares on the market- Blackmagic Design’s Davinci Resolve Studio. This was not the case when Blackmagic release the original BMPCC. So we have yet another huge addition of value to this camera.

2. Raw 3:1

Raw 3:1 is a new and beautiful codec that has helped swell the wave of excitement with the new release of the BMPCC 4K. Supposedly consumers will receive many of the benefits of RAW DNG but with much less of a data burden. And it has more of a chance of being compatible with Apple products such as FCPX.

3. Full HDMI Port

If after releasing the original BMPCC Blackmagic would have rereleased it with only the minor improvement of a full HDMI port, sales probably would have risen a fair amount.

However, now that they have released the BMPCC 4K with a full HDMI port, there is slightly less of a need for one because the new BMPCC 4K display is a respectable 5 inch bright touchscreen display with lovely new features (uploadable 3D Luts). Either way, we now have a full HDMI port in case we need it.

The Cons

1. LP - E6 Battery

This was certainly an underwhelming aspect of the release. The batteries on the original BMPCC were pretty much garbage and these aren’t too great of an upgrade. For most users of this camera, anything less than an hour long battery life simply isn’t going to suffice.

Hopefully, considering this battery is associated with the Canon line of cameras, a battery grip of sorts will come out specifically for this camera.

2. MFT Mount

I’m actually not hating on them for sticking with the micro four thirds sensor, which they could have expanded on with something like an aps-c or full frame sensor. My gripe is with the mount.

Maybe I’m just selfish, but I would have loved to see the same move they did with the BMCC and release three different mounts with this camera- an EF mount, an F mount and an MFT mount.

3. Incompatible with the BMPCC Speedbooster

I realize this will only effect the few that bought the metabones speedbooster that was specific to the BMPCC. However, if you did purchase the speedbooster (like I did), then this is a particular slap in the face.

The sensor on the BMPCC 4K was adjusted ever so slightly that now when you put your BMPCC speedbooster on the BMPCC 4K, there will be vignetting. Ouch.

4. 13 Stops of Dynamic Range

Now, this is much less of a con than it is a disappointment. In fact, for me, it was the biggest disappointment.

Whenever I see a new camera release, dynamic range, is the first spec I’m interested in followed by codec. Blackmagic certainly has the codec down and is continuing to grow on that with the new RAW 3:1. But unfortunately the dynamic range is staying the same. Even fourteen stops would have been a great improvement.

All hope is not lost however. Some speculate that Blackmagic will have a firmware update at some point that will take the cameras sensor up to fifteen stops.

Honorable Mentions

1. Lack of Filters

Most of us aren’t bound to studio for our shoots. And everyone who shoots outside with a Blackmagic needs to have an IR Filter. For some reason Blackmagic Design does not coat their sensors with an IR filter, so consumers are left to purchase expansive IR/ND cut filters for their lenses. Unfortunately, Blackmagic didn’t include either an IR or ND filter solution on the BMPCC 4K.

2. Non Swiveling Display

Oddly enough, this camera is being marketed towards vloggers. While I haven’t seen many vloggers on board with even the ergonomically sized BMPCC, the BMPCC 4K has features that are seemingly geared towards these people.

All in all, this doesn’t seem to be the best solution for most vloggers, but a non swiveling display really drives that point home.

5 Comments

  • Nick says:

    I’m going to have to respectfully disagree with you in regards to most of your cons.

    With the exception of Sony E lenses, almost any lens can be adapted to Micro four thirds mounts. Not exactly something most people would be very disappointed about. The bigger bummer is the crop factor but a larger sensor is a lot to ask for. Not compatible with the bmpcc speedbooster- Because the sensor is much bigger. Necessary casualty if you want a next level camera from the original. It would have been a bigger disappointment if it was still a super 16 sized sensor. The original pocket having 13 stops of dynamic range was unprecedented- along with having RAW, it was the wow factor for the camera. 13 stops is still competitive compared to cameras nearly 10 times its price. Sure, its not better than the original but the original was next level.

    I’ll agree with you on the battery. I find it underwhelming considering people were so vocal about the crappiness of the battery on the original.

    • Thanks for the comment Nick! I’m aware many people are satisfied with the MFT mount. Again, it’s a bit selfish of a choice to make it a con, but I would have liked to see multiple choices for mounts like they have previously released. If they can do it for the BMCC and BMPC 4K why not the BMPCC 4k? Of course I’m not complaining, just putting my opinion out there. Overall I’m incredibly excited for the camera. Thanks again for reading!

  • Ricardo says:

    For users like me, comming from Canon, 13 stops is a lot. Canon only has 9 stops in RAW images, video is worse + 8bit and H264.

  • Rob Stowell says:

    I’m cool with MFT and the bigger sensor (meaning the speedbooster won’t work – agree it’s a bummer for anyone who has one – keep yr bmpcc!) is a bonus. The 2.9 x crop made finding a decent wide angle hard. That should all be fixed now. Dynamic range: the 5D testers found about half a stop more in this cam from the bmpcc (11.2 to 11.6 stops). That is a bonus – and if it can be increased, cool. The low noise at high ISO more than compensates, for me. Can’t wait to get my hands on it. The biggest ‘con’ right now is the wait time for pre-orders 🙂

  • ASHISH PAUL GEORGE says:

    As a Cinematographer and a filmmaker I actually love the BMPCC4K. But i will buy the GH5s.
    For me, the only two drawbacks of the unit when compared to other mirrorless cameras are, not weatherproof as I most of my shoot happens in Dust and moist conditions, and the other drawback is the screen as it will not TILT forget Swiveling Display.

    THE BIGGEST DRAWBACK FOR ME IS THAT IN INDIA BLACKMAGIC DESIGN DOSENT HAVE A SERVICE CENTER AND THE EXTRA IMPORT DUTIES. WHEN I ENQUIRED THE PRICE IS ALMOST TO THE SAME AS GH5S.

    I love the MFT mount but would have been extremely happy if it had multiple options.

Leave a Reply

[INFOGRAPHIC]
[INFOGRAPHIC]
[INFOGRAPHIC]
[INFOGRAPHIC]